Real-Time Rendering in VFX: Unreal Engine vs. Traditional Pipelines
Share
Real-Time Rendering in VFX: Unreal Engine vs. Traditional Pipelines
Introduction
Real-time rendering is revolutionizing VFX workflows, enabling artists to see immediate results without waiting for hours of pre-rendered frames. With the rise of game engines like Unreal Engine, real-time technology is now being adopted in film production, changing how visual effects, animation, and virtual production are executed.
But how does real-time rendering compare to traditional VFX pipelines using software like Maya, Houdini, and RenderMan? Can it replace traditional pre-rendering techniques, or does it still have limitations? In this article, we’ll explore the differences between real-time rendering and traditional rendering pipelines, their advantages and drawbacks, and how they are shaping the future of VFX.
What Is Real-Time Rendering in VFX?
Real-time rendering is the process of generating high-quality visuals instantly, allowing artists to see final-frame results without long render times. Unlike traditional VFX workflows, where rendering can take hours or even days per frame, real-time engines like Unreal Engine 5 and Unity enable instant feedback, interactive lighting adjustments, and dynamic scene updates.
🔹 Example:
In The Mandalorian, Unreal Engine was used to create real-time environments displayed on LED walls, eliminating the need for green screens in many scenes.
Key Features of Real-Time Rendering:
✅ Immediate visual feedback – Artists can adjust lighting, materials, and animations instantly.
✅ Real-time ray tracing – Advanced rendering techniques improve realism with dynamic reflections and shadows.
✅ Virtual production support – Used in LED volumes and real-time compositing.
✅ Game engine-based workflows – Tools like Unreal Engine 5 provide cinematic rendering without pre-render times.
Traditional Rendering in VFX: How It Works
Traditional rendering is the standard pipeline used in high-end VFX, where images are pre-rendered using ray tracing and complex shading calculations to achieve photorealistic results.
🔹 How It Works:
✅ Artists build and animate scenes in software like Maya or Houdini.
✅ Rendering engines like Arnold, V-Ray, Redshift, or RenderMan compute light, materials, and reflections frame by frame.
✅ Render farms process multiple frames, which are then composited in Nuke or After Effects.
🔹 Example:
Films like Avengers: Endgame and Dune use traditional render pipelines to achieve high-fidelity CGI characters, environments, and simulations.
Advantages of Traditional Rendering:
✅ Extreme photorealism – High-quality ray-traced reflections, subsurface scattering, and global illumination.
✅ Full control over every pixel – Artists can fine-tune details with no hardware limitations.
✅ Used for complex FX simulations – Fire, water, destruction, and hair simulations require offline rendering.
Disadvantages of Traditional Rendering:
❌ Slow render times – Some scenes take several hours per frame to render.
❌ Expensive hardware requirements – Requires massive render farms.
❌ Limited real-time feedback – Artists must wait for previews before seeing final results.
🔹 Example:
Pixar’s Toy Story 4 took several hundred CPU years to render, using one of the most powerful render farms in the world.
Real-Time Rendering vs. Traditional Pipelines
| Feature | Real-Time Rendering (Unreal Engine) | Traditional Rendering (V-Ray, Arnold, RenderMan) |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Instant rendering | Hours per frame |
| Realism | High quality, but not as detailed as offline rendering | Maximum photorealism |
| Flexibility | Interactive scene changes, dynamic lighting updates | Requires re-rendering for changes |
| Hardware | Requires powerful GPUs, but no render farm | Requires large CPU-based render farms |
| Best For | Virtual production, previs, interactive environments | High-end VFX, complex simulations |
🔹 Example:
For The Batman (2022), Unreal Engine was used for previsualization and real-time lighting tests, while final CGI was rendered using traditional methods.
How Unreal Engine Is Changing VFX Workflows
Unreal Engine 5 is leading the real-time VFX revolution, offering cinematic-quality rendering, real-time ray tracing, and dynamic scene creation.
🔹 Key Features of Unreal Engine for VFX:
✅ Nanite Virtualized Geometry – Enables high-resolution assets without performance loss.
✅ Lumen Global Illumination – Real-time ray-traced lighting and reflections.
✅ MetaHuman Creator – AI-powered realistic digital humans.
✅ Virtual Production Support – Integrated with LED volumes and real-time camera tracking.
🔹 Example:
In The Mandalorian, Unreal Engine’s real-time lighting system allowed directors to adjust sunlight and shadows instantly on LED screens, providing real-time cinematography for CGI environments.
Can Real-Time Rendering Replace Traditional Pipelines?
While real-time rendering is improving rapidly, it still has some limitations compared to traditional methods:
✅ What Real-Time Rendering Can Replace:
✅ Previsualization (Previs) – Directors can visualize scenes instantly.
✅ Virtual Production – Used for LED walls, real-time green screen compositing.
✅ Real-Time Animation – Great for game cinematics and animated films.
✅ Background Environments – Used for large-scale CGI landscapes.
🔹 Example:
In Thor: Love and Thunder, real-time backgrounds were rendered on LED volumes, eliminating the need for green screens in many shots.
❌ What Traditional Rendering Is Still Needed For:
❌ Complex FX Simulations – Real-time engines struggle with high-end water, fire, and destruction effects.
❌ Ultra-Photorealistic CGI – Real-time rendering still lacks full ray-tracing accuracy for extreme realism.
❌ Feature Films with High-Detail Close-Ups – Animated films like Frozen 2 still use traditional rendering for subsurface scattering in skin and fur.
🔹 Example:
For Avatar: The Way of Water, traditional path-traced rendering was required to achieve photo-real water simulations, which real-time rendering could not yet match.
The Future of Real-Time Rendering in VFX
With advancements in AI-driven rendering, GPU acceleration, and hybrid real-time + offline workflows, the gap between real-time and traditional pipelines is shrinking.
🔹 Upcoming Trends:
✅ AI-Powered Rendering – AI-assisted denoising and upscaling will improve real-time rendering quality.
✅ Hybrid Rendering Pipelines – Combining real-time backgrounds with offline-rendered CGI characters.
✅ Cloud-Based Real-Time Rendering – Future game engines will run high-quality renders on cloud GPUs, reducing hardware limitations.
🔹 Example:
In The Matrix Resurrections, a mix of Unreal Engine real-time rendering and traditional ray tracing was used to create a hybrid CGI workflow.
Conclusion
Real-time rendering is transforming VFX pipelines, offering faster workflows, instant feedback, and interactive cinematography. While Unreal Engine and real-time tools are making virtual production, previs, and real-time animation more efficient, traditional rendering remains essential for high-end CGI, complex physics simulations, and ultra-photorealistic visuals.
With AI-enhanced real-time technology and hybrid rendering, the future of VFX is a fusion of both methods, allowing studios to create faster, more dynamic, and visually stunning films.
🚀 Want to explore real-time VFX? Start experimenting with Unreal Engine today!
References
- The VES Handbook of Visual Effects – Jeffrey A. Okun & Susan Zwerman.
- Unreal Engine 5 Documentation – Real-Time VFX and Virtual Production.
- SIGGRAPH 2023 – The Future of Real-Time Rendering in Film Production.
- Behind the Scenes – The Making of The Mandalorian (LED Volumes and Virtual Production).
- Pixar's RenderMan Blog – The Role of Traditional Rendering in Modern VFX.